Pretty in Pink Pineapple Pie

History & Origins

This pink pineapple pie was inspired by a recipe from The New Butterick Cookbook, published in 1924.

I love trying vintage recipes, such as brownies from 1934, rice pudding from 7th century Persia, or chocolate chip cookies courtesy of someone’s grandmother. So when I saw this simple-looking pineapple pie recipe on /r/Old_Recipes, I had to give it a try!

Experiment Results

A commenter mentioned using butter in place of the egg yolks, so I subbed in my trusty ol’ Becel margarine. Also, being the lazy person that I am, I decided to experiment with blending the pineapple instead of going to the trouble of grating it. Which turned out to be a great decision because it resulted in a silky smooth pie filling.

Pink Pineapple

Around the time I was testing this recipe, I was starting to see those trendy pink pineapples pop up at my local Costco. (You can read about my taste review of the PinkGlow pineapple here.)

I decided to use some of the fruit to make a batch of this pie, and it turned out beautiful. The colour of the pureed pineapple deepened as it simmered over the stove, to the point where it looked almost more red than pink.

This would make a perfect Valentine’s Day dessert. I know I’m publishing this in May, but, keep it bookmarked for next year I guess? Anyway, let’s talk about how to make this pink pineapple pie!

What You’ll Need

First and foremost, you’ll need a baked pie crust. You can use a storebought pastry shell or make one from scratch. Here are some homemade options:

• If you have a stand mixer, this Crisco pie crust is my go-to.
• I’ve also tried this gluten-free and oil-free pie crust.

If you make your own pastry, you can use a cookie cutter on the leftover dough and bake them, for decorating the top of the pie.

Now onto the ingredients for the filling:

You can use fresh, frozen, or canned pineapple for this pie. I used a PinkGlow pineapple to give the pie its natural pink colour, but of course you can use a regular pineapple for a golden yellow pie. This recipe is also a great opportunity to use up the hard core of your pineapple—which has plenty of sweetness, but is rather too tough to chew through. A powerful blender will take care of that problem. Just chop it up into rough chunks and throw it into your blender along with the rest of the ingredients. The less food waste the better, is my motto. 🍍

In addition to the natural sweetness of the pineapple, you’ll need to some extra sugar. It also works really well with sweetener alternatives like granulated stevia or monkfruit. Less processed alternatives like maple syrup, jaggery, and brown sugar will darken the pie filling, but if you’re not worried about the colour you can certainly use them.

Cornstarch is the required thickening agent for this pineapple pie. I have tested with tapioca starch, but it doesn’t achieve the correct texture so I don’t recommend it at all. Not sure about other starches like potato starch or wheat starch, but if you do try one of them, please leave a comment about how it worked out for you.

Just a bit of salt helps bring out the sweetness.

A few spoonfuls of vegan butter or margarine add richness, helping the pie achieve a rounder flavour.

Finally, you’ll want half of a lemon or lime to provide an extra bit of tropical tang. If you’ve got the time to grate the zest, I strongly recommend it.

Step-by-Step Process

The process for this pineapple pie recipe couldn’t be simpler. Most of the work is done by the trusty blender. Make sure your pie crust is baked and ready before starting on the filling. (You can also watch the video for a narrated tutorial.)

Step 1: Add chopped pineapple, cornstarch, sugar, and salt to a blender.

Step 2: Purée on high speed until smooth.

Step 3: Pour the mixture into a saucepan on medium heat.

Step 4: Once it starts to bubble, go in with your spatula and stir constantly until it begins to thicken.

Warning: Don’t slack on this step. If you don’t keep up the stirring, it will splatter everywhere.

Step 5: As soon as it thickens (see the video for the right consistency), turn off the heat.

Step 6: Stir in the butter or margarine until it melts into the pie filling mixture.

Step 7: Squeeze in the lemon or lime juice.

Step 8: Pour pie filling into the pie crust.

Step 9: Smooth the filling with the back of a spatula.

Step 10 (Optional): Top with leftover bits of pie crust.

Tip: Allow pie to chill to room temperature before slicing and serving.

Make Ahead & Storage Tips

Room temperature: Fruit pies taste best when they’re kept on the counter, so the best way is to store pink pineapple pie is on the counter, in an airtight container, for up to two days.

Fridge: If you need to store this pie for longer, keep it inside the fridge in a ziploc bag for up to seven days.

Freezer: This pie also freezes surprisingly well. I expected it to get soggy, but it stayed intact even after freezing and thawing. Store in a sealed ziploc bag or wrapped tightly in several layers of plastic wrap for up to three months.

Do not store any whipped cream type toppings with the pie. I recommend adding the cream just before serving.

Diet Substitutions

If you’re following a specific diet or need to be aware of allergies, here are a couple of ways you can modify this recipe:

• Gluten-free: Use a gluten-free pie crust. The pink pineapple pie you see in all the pictures of this post are actually made with a gluten-free and oil-free pie crust, specifically this one. It’s not the same as a regular flaky buttery pie, but as a vehicle for delivering the pineapple filling, it does the job.
• Sugar-free: Swap out the sugar for alternatives like granulated stevia or monkfruit. I have made the pie with both Truvia and Lakanto brand sweeteners and honestly can’t taste a difference. Less processed alternatives like maple syrup, jaggery, and brown sugar will darken the pie filling, but if you’re not worried about the colour you can certainly use them.

If you made this recipe with a successful substitution, please let me know! Post a comment describing what you did so I can add it to this section and help future readers. (Leave your name blank if you don’t want to be credited.)

More Vintage Recipes